Not Every Women's Apparel Retailer Is Declining

J Jill posts another quarter of growth

Author: Andria Cheng

May 31, 2017

Amidst a sea of declines among US women’s clothing retailers, at least one store is bucking the trend.


J Jill Inc. on Wednesday reported a 9.9% Q1 comparable sales gain, its 19th gain in the last 21 quarters. The gain didn’t come at the cost of profit as gross margin widened and adjusted profit jumped 50%. The Quincy, Mass.-based retailer forecast sales will continue to rise in the “high-single-digit” for both Q2 and this year.

“We are confident we have the right formula and approach in place to continue to drive these consistent positive results and to deliver against our goals,” said President and Chief Executive Paula Bennett. “This quarter further exemplifies how well positioned we are to continue to capture market share.”

J Jill’s results and Bennett’s confidence stood in sharp contrast to the declining sales and cautionary remarks by the company’s rivals. Ann Taylor and Dressbarn parent Ascena, for instance, recently forecast that its quarterly and full-year same-store sales will drop 8% and as much as 7% respectively. Chico’s FAS Inc. Q1 same-store sales slumped nearly 9% after declines at both its Chico’s and White House Black Market chains. Between 2012 and 2016, J Jill has outperformed not only Ascena and Chico’s but also other rivals including Christopher & Banks, New York & Co. and Banana Republic parent Gap, according to Retail Metrics data.

Related Links

The Haves and the Have-Nots

A Time of Diverging Fortunes for the Retail Sector

In another example, just as retail executives such as Ascena President and CEO David Jaffe have noted “industrywide traffic headwinds” and “unprecedented secular change that’s disruptive to traditional business model,” J Jill has benefited from having its about 280 stores located in the so-called premium malls and lifestyle centers, which are still generating traffic, unlike older, lower-end retail centers, many of them seeing store closings from such retailers as Macy’s, JC Penney and Sears.

To be sure, it remains to be seen whether J Jill, which generated $639 million in sales last year, can sustain its growth as it grows bigger. One of its closest rivals, Chico’s, for instance, generated $2.48 billion in sales last year.

J Jill, which targets 40-  to 65-year-olds who are college educated and have household income of at least $150,000, also is ahead of its competition on one metric that’s become increasingly important. Direct to consumer sales for the company, mostly from ecommerce, represented 42.6% of Q1 sales from 40.7% a year earlier. The retailer expects that to increase to half of total the next few years.

company data

Apparel Retailers

See revenue, real estate, store productivity data and more for apparel retailers

That’s higher than all but one among dozens of apparel retailers tracked in eMarketer’s company database. Only Lands’ End generated a higher percentage of sales (86%) online. Among other women’s retailers, Urban Outfitters’s Anthropologie, for instance, generated more than a third of sales online, New York & Co., 25%, and Ann Taylor, 21%.

With big data analytics and personalization the big buzzwords in the industry, J Jill said in its S1 filing earlier this year its data can match approximately 97% of transactions to an identifiable customer, which the company said is “significantly ahead of the industry standard.”

J. Jill “showed its omni-channel model and data-driven decision making are viable strategies in this evolving retail environment” as rivals are “plagued by traffic declines and store closures ahead,” said Jefferies analyst Randal Konik.

With many retailers struggling to retain customer loyalty, the company also said in the S1 filing that about 70% of its pro forma fiscal 2015 gross sales came from customers who have been buying from it for at least five years. Those customers spend nearly twice as much and shop 1.5 times more per year than a new customer.

Related Links

Loyalty Pains

Marketers Love Loyalty Programs. Few Do Them Right.

Echoing other retailers, J Jill said its private label credit card is a contributor to customer loyalty as average transaction per card holder is more than double that of non-card holders.

Its Facebook page is one sign of that loyalty, with such customer comments as “Love your clothes” and “pretty colors always” sprinkled throughout.

“I’m a very loyal customer,” said a customer with a Facebook account name Marian Marchiano Kelly on the company’s Facebook page. “I live in NYC and have my pick of retail stores but always go with J Jill.”